The Best Eyebrow Pens for Creating Natural-Looking Brows With Fine, Hair-Like Strokes

For years, we relied heavily on eyebrow pencils, but now there is a variety of products to help us fill in our brows, from powders to pomades. Recently, eyebrow pens have been trending, with Spate noting searches grew by 2.1M year-over-year. What sets a brow pen apart from a pencil? The ultra-fine tip creates hair-like lines that the naked eye can rarely tell apart from the real thing. If you’re looking to get a natural look when filling in your sparse brows, rather than creating a block of color on your forehead, we suggest trying an eyebrow pen, and these are the best on the market.

1 / 6

Benefit Cosmetics Mighty Fine Waterproof Brow Pen ($28)

The triple-prong tip on this brow pen helps make your makeup routine smoother and faster. The super-fine tips mimic the look of natural hair for fuller-looking, but not overdone, brows. A survey found that 99 percent of users said the pen easily fills in sparse areas, and 98 percent said it helped their brows look defined.

• BUY ON ULTA – $28
• BUY ON SEPHORA – $28

2 / 6

Urban Decay Brow Blade 2-in-1 Eyebrow Pen + Waterproof Pencil ($28)

If you’re stuck between using a pen or pencil on your brows, this is the product for you. This two-in-one pen and pencil lets you choose your adventure or combine approaches. The pen side creates fine, hair-like strokes, while the pencil is great for filling out and shaping larger areas.

 

• BUY ON ULTA – $28
• BUY ON SEPHORA – $28

3 / 6

L’Oréal Faux Brow Ultra Fine Double-Brush Tip Brow Filling Pen ($13)

The ultra-thin tip on this dual-tip brush creates fine, precise, hair-like marks. “This product is a winner for us ladies who have little to no brows left. I’m 64 and this product has given me back confidence in my all day (13hrs) appearance,” wrote one user.

• BUY ON AMAZON – $13
• BUY ON ULTA – $13

4 / 6

Glossier Brow Flick ($18)

Brow Flick is a classic for a reason. The micro-fine detailing pen still stands up years after its launch, competing with newer innovations. The feather-like strokes blend in seamlessly with your actual brows for natural-looking added depth and dimension.

• BUY ON GLOSSIER – $18
• BUY ON SEPHORA – $18

5 / 6

Revolution Beauty Instant Brow Hair Pen ($9)

This one is a bargain with six prongs all for under $10. One reviewer who lost her eyebrows due to chemotherapy writes that this is easy to use and the best product she has tried. She credits it for giving her a bit of her confidence back.

• BUY NOW – $9

6 / 6

Anastasia Micro-Stroking Detailing Brow Pen ($26)

The firmness of this brush tip helps it stand out among the competition. It easily and naturally creates the illusion of a full brow. “I have absolutely NO eyebrows, so this is a lifesaver…I think I’ll order about 100 of them in case you stop making it!” writes one reviewer.

• BUY ON ULTA – $26
• BUY ON REVOLVE – $26