The Prettiest Luxury Eye Makeup We’re Obsessed With for Fall

Jewel-toned shadow, defined brows and full, fluttery lashes

Britt Fallon

Published: Oct 10, 2025

We may earn commission from links on this page. Each product featured has been vetted and chosen by our editors.

Courtesy of Sarah Creal and Chanel

This article first appeared in the Fall 2025 issue of NewBeauty. Click here to subscribe

A spotlight on the season’s biggest eye makeup trends, including jewel-toned shadow, defined brows and full, fluttery lashes.

1 / 7

La Beauté Louis Vuitton LV Ombres in Force of Nature 951 ($250)

La Beauté Louis Vuitton has finally arrived, and LV Ombres in Force of Nature 951 is a standout among the eight-palette, refillable eyeshadow collection. Curated by Pat McGrath, the brand’s creative director of cosmetics, and housed in an heirloom compact you’ll want to keep forever, the four versatile shades capture “the unique patina journey of [the brand’s] heritage VVN leather,” from golden bronze and luminous ivory to rich brown and earthy green.

BUY NOW – $250

2 / 7

Christian Louboutin Les Yeux Noirs Aqua Extrema ($60)

Christian Louboutin’s Les Yeux Noirs Aqua Extrema is its first waterproof mascara utilizing a 4-D formula, which means it provides volume, length, curve and definition all at once. While some waterproof options can be harsh on lashes, this one contains pansy extract and cherry blossom to nourish them and reduce fallout.

BUY NOW – $60

Christian Louboutin Les Yeux Noirs Aqua Extrema

3 / 7

CHANEL Les Ombres 4 Boutons Multi-Effect Quadra Eyeshadow in Couture ($86)

CHANEL’s limited-edition Les Ombres 4 Boutons Multi-Effect Quadra Eyeshadow in Couture is almost too pretty to use. Embossed with the brand’s signature fashion motifs, each of the four soft-shimmer shades (two chocolatey-brown and two nude) makes its own glam beauty statement.

BUY NOW – $86

4 / 7

Bobbi Brown Cosmetics Dual-Ended Long-Wear Cream Eyeshadow Sticks ($43)

Developed in six new thoughtfully curated shade pairings that reflect emerging color trends for fall, like Café and Gilded Green, Bobbi Brown Cosmetics Dual-Ended Long-Wear Cream Eyeshadow Sticks offer a duo to complement every fall fashion essential. Pro tip: Use a shimmery shade all over the lids and a matte hue as liner

5 / 7

Sisley Paris Phyto-Eye Palette in Tender Toffee ($125)

Whether your goal is business casual or evening glam, Sisley Paris’s long-wear Phyto-Eye Palette in Tender Toffee contains a mix of warm nude and mocha shades in three finishes to create gorgeous, multidimensional eye looks.

6 / 7

Sarah Creal Beauty Intensity Gel Eyeliner ($35)

Available in six stunning shades that cater to every eye color, Sarah Creal Beauty Intensity Gel Eyeliner glides on like silk so there’s no tugging, even on crepey lids. The waterproof formula stays in place until you wash it off, and won’t irritate sensitive eyes.

BUY NOW – $35

7 / 7

YSL Beauty Couture Mini Clutch Luxury Eyeshadow Palette in 820 Majestic Riad ($69)

On-trend for fall, YSL Beauty debuts its new jewel-toned Couture Mini Clutch Luxury Eyeshadow Palette in 820 Majestic Riad. The rich burgundy theme, complete with corresponding neutrals in satin, matte and metallic finishes, can be mixed and matched for every occasion. It’s the perfect pairing for your favorite LBD.

Find a Doctor

Find a NewBeauty "Top Beauty Doctor" Near you