10 of the Best Beauty Products on Amazon, According to NewBeauty Shoppers

Every month we like to take stock of the beauty products our readers are loving most and where they’re getting them. In September, skin care was on top of everyone’s minds, and shopping on Amazon to get it. What made the top 10 list of Amazon beauty buys last month? Serums, eye creams, retinols, face masks and body lotions specifically recommended by dermatologists, plastic surgeons and additional experts were undeniably the most popular items. To see the entire list, what they’re praised for and fast access to shop them yourselves, read on.

1 / 10

Dermalogica Phyto Nature Lifting Eye Cream ($118)

This year’s NewBeauty Awards winner for Best Firming Eye Cream works on both the entire undereye area and the upper eyelids by utilizing peptides and potent botanicals to address fine lines, wrinkles, dryness and loss of elasticity.

• BUY NOW – $118

2 / 10

La Roche-Posay Lipikar Urea 10% Roughness Smoothing Lotion ($23)

Two dermatologists we spoke too told us La Roche Posay’s Lipikar Urea 10% Lotion is one of their favorites for hydrating dry and/or mature skin and smoothing bumpy skin, thanks to the titular urea, plus shea butter and allantoin.

• BUY NOW – $23

3 / 10

CO2Lift Carboxy Gel Treatment Facial Masks ($186)

When we asked dermatologists to share their favorite face masks, several said the CO2Lift Carboxy Gel Treatment. “My favorite face masks are the CO2 Gel Lifts,” says Montclair, NJ dermatologist Jeanine B. Downie. “They help to rehydrate my face and my body and can be used on mosquito bites and poison ivy, as well as having anti-aging benefits for the face and neck.” New York dermatologist Doris Day, MD also loves the CO2 Gel Lifts for instant rejuvenation, and Southlake, TX dermatologist Janine Hopkins, MD also can’t get enough, explaining that “A very high-end mask treatment that is truly amazing is the CO2Lift Face Masks for hydration, oxygenation and skin tightening.”

• BUY NOW – $186

4 / 10

NUTRI-OX Gentle Shampoo Normal for Thinning Hair ($17)

“This formula is a great option if scalp sensitivity is an issue,” says our editor of Nutri-Ox’s Gentle Shampoo. “The key ingredients [peppermint oil, biotin, nettle extract, sunflower extract and gingko biloba] work to unclog follicles, refresh the scalp and improve the appearance of fullness in just one week,” adds trichologist Mandy Buechner.

• BUY NOW – $17

5 / 10

StriVectin Tighten and Lift Peptight 360 Degree Eye Serum ($72)

“This formula, like many of StriVectin’s, is great at targeting crepey skin, making it good for tightening up the upper eyes,” our editor previously reported. “After eight weeks, 96 percent of users were clinically graded to have less visible lines and wrinkles around the eyes,” she adds. (To see more jaw-dropping eye cream before and afters, click here.)

• BUY NOW – $72

6 / 10

RoC Derm Correxion Retinol Firming Serum Stick ($30)

This year’s Awards winner for Best Serum Stick is affordable, mess-free, dermatologist-approved and skin-firming, thanks to retinol and THPE, an ingredient that is clinically proven to increase skin’s firmness by 90 percent.

• BUY NOW – $30

7 / 10

Avène Cicalfate+ Restorative Protective Cream ($26)

French pharmacy legend Avène makes the September top 10 list twice. First up: the equally-legendary Cicalfate+ Restorative Cream. It’s praised on end by dermatologists, celebrities (Hailey Bieber and Sofia Richie Grainge are just two) and shoppers for having over 40 skin care uses, from scar care and nighttime moisturizer to rash cream, and safe for the whole family. I always have a tube in my medicine cabinet!

• BUY NOW – $26

8 / 10

K18 Leave-In Molecular Hair Mask ($75)

The multi-year award-winning hair mask from K18 continues to the one of the most popular beauty products with NewBeauty readers—in fact, it was named Favorite Bond Repair Mask in this year’s Readers Choice Awards. Backed by biotech, this leave-in treatment reconnects broken hair bonds in just four minutes, restoring bounce, strength and smoothness without rinsing.

• BUY NOW – $75

9 / 10

Avène Retrinal 0.1% Intensive Multi-Corrective Cream ($68)

The second Avène product on the list is a retinaldehyde cream that’s dermatologist-recommended for sensitive skin types (thanks to the addition of hyaluronic acid and niacinamide). Phoenix, AZ dermatologist Karan Lal, MD, lists this as his all-time holy grail: “It has antioxidants and is three times stronger than retinol!”

• BUY NOW – $68

10 / 10

The Ordinary Matrixyl 10% + HA ($11)

This water-based serum blends two generations of wrinkle-reducing Matrixyl peptides with hyaluronic acid to soften fine lines and boost hydration overall, leading to a plumper and firmer complexion. With an $11 price tag and nearly 2,000 five-star reviews on Amazon alone, it’s a no brainer skin serum.

• BUY NOW – $11